Gotham Bagels — home

The Menu

Pick your market

Same hand-rolled, kettle-boiled standard everywhere — with a menu tuned to each market.

Chicago & Lake Geneva MenuMadison Menu

Rolled, boiled, and baked to perfection

Meet the Bagels

All of our menu items are made fresh, in-house. Because of this, the menu offerings may differ slightly between locations. To check out the full and updated menu, click “Order Now” and choose your favorite location!

  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled plain bagelPlainaka the PLN
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled onion bagelOnionaka the ONI
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled everything bagelEverythingaka the EVY
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled super egg everything bagelSuper Egg Everythingaka the SEE
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled salt bagelSaltaka the SAL
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled pumpernickel bagelPumpernickelaka the PUP
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled poppy seed bagelPoppyaka the POP
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled cinnamon raisin bagelCinnamon Raisinaka the CIR
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled honey whole wheat bagelHoney Whole Wheataka the WWH
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled egg bagelEggaka the EGG
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled sesame bagelSesameaka the SES
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled asiago cheese bagelAsiagoaka the ASO
  • Gotham Bagels honey whole wheat everything bagelHoney Whole Wheat Everything
  • Gotham Bagels hand-rolled cinnamon sugar bagelCinnamon Sugar
Order Now