The Menu
Chicago & Lake Geneva Menu
Order online from your location
Bagels
- Single BagelOne perfect, hand-rolled bagel. Loose Bagels do not come sliced.
- Half Dozen BagelsChoose 6.
- New York Dozen (13)Choose your favorite 13.
Hand-Rolled Bagels
- Plain
- Sesame
- Poppy
- Salt
- Everything
- Asiago
- Onion
- Egg
- Egg Everything
- Cinnamon Raisin
- Cinnamon Sugar
- Pumpernickel
- Honey Whole Wheat
- Honey WW Everything
Cream Cheese
- House-Whipped Cream Cheese8 oz.
House-Made Cream Cheese
- Plain
- Vegan Plain
- Scallion
- Vegan Scallion
- Vegetable
- Strawberry
- Maple Cinnamon
- Lox
- Seasonal Flavor
Sandwiches
Classic Sandwiches
- Bacon, Egg & CheddarThick-cut bacon, fried egg*, aged cheddar (turkey bacon available on request)
- Spicy Sausage, Egg & CheddarSpicy Italian sausage, fried egg*, aged cheddar
- Brighton BeachPremium Atlantic cold-smoked salmon*, cream cheese, tomato, red onion, arugula, capers
- Traditional Tuna Fish*Tuna, arugula, tomato, red onion
- The AmagansettSmoked whitefish salad*, arugula, cucumber, tomato, red onion
- Pizza BagelPizza sauce, aged mozzarella, choice of pepperoni or spicy Italian sausage, romano, oregano. Served sandwich style, closed-faced. (Available only at Chicago locations)
Simple Sandwiches
- Bagel & Cream CheeseWith butter, cream cheese, or vegan spread (strawberry, lox, or seasonal cream cheese +0.35)
- One Egg Sandwich*
- Lox* & Cream Cheese
Signature Sandwiches
- OMFGNashville fried chicken, thick-cut bacon, fried egg*, aged cheddar, spicy aioli
- Pastrami & Egg*
- The Yellow C.A.B.Bacon, cheddar, avocado, arugula, tomato, mayo
- The Rocky's DeliThick-cut bacon, fried egg*, aged cheddar, potato latke, spicy ketchup
- The Long IslandSmoked turkey breast, fontina cheese, arugula, tomato, mayo
- The VVegan scallion cream cheese, poblano salad, tomato, arugula, avocado
- The WilliamsburgPastrami, NY strong mustard, coleslaw
Seasonal Specials
- Ask about our seasonal specials!
Deli & Extras
Items from the Deli can be ordered in 1/2 Pound increments. Check out our Catering Platters for your next get together.
- Lox1/2 pound of Northern Atlantic cold-smoked salmon. Comes with arugula, tomato, red onion, capers.
- Traditional Tuna Salad1/2 pound house-made tuna salad.
- Smoked Whitefish Salad1/2 pound house-made smoked whitefish salad.
- House-Cured Pastrami1/2 pound, comes with pickles and arugula.
- House-Cured Roast Turkey1/2 pound, comes with pickles and arugula.
- Potato Latkes6 house-made potato latkes.
- Traditional Matzo Ball SoupQuart of broth with 3 matzo balls. Served cold.
- Gotham Cole Slaw1/2 LB
- Gotham Frozen Bagels5 frozen sliced day-old bagels.
- Gotham's Finest Pickles1 Jar, brined to perfection.
- Snake Bite Hot SauceOur very own smoked carrot hot sauce. 5 oz.
- Great Lakes Kettle ChipsMade from fresh skin-on Michigan potatoes.
- Bag of Bagel ChipsSeasoned with Gotham's Finest Everything Seasoning.
- Everything Spice8oz of our special Everything blend.
- Homemade CookiesChocolate chunk brown butter, Black & white
Beverages
Coffee & Espresso
Serving Passion House Coffee.
- Hot Coffee
- Cold Brew
- Sweet Cream Cold Brew
- Espresso
- Americano
- Cappuccino
- LatteAdd honey, vanilla, cinnamon, sugar free vanilla, lavender or raspberry syrup *ask your barista for seasonal syrup flavors
- Mocha
- White Chocolate Mocha
- Coffee BoxServes 8 - 12, includes cups, sugars, creamers, and stirrers.
Specialty Lattes
- The Bee's KneesFloral lavender and rich honey combined with your choice of milk and a delicious espresso blend from Passion House Coffee. The perfect spring drink!
- Just PeachyA delightful drink that combines the sweetness of peaches with the rich creaminess of white chocolate and the boldness of Passion House Coffee espresso.
Tea & More
- Matcha Latte
- Sweet Cream Matcha Latte
- London FogLondon Fog Tea Latte. Earl grey with vanilla, lavender, and steamed milk of choice.
- Sweet & Spicy ChaiSpicy Chai with Cinnamon Syrup.
- Chai Tea LatteChai tea with your choice of milk!
- TeaOrganic Rishi tea blends: Hibiscus berry, Earl Grey, Jade green, Mint green.
- Iced TeaBlack unsweetened tea brewed in-house.
- LemonadeHouse-made with fresh squeezed lemon juice and pure cane sugar.
- Arnold PalmerEqual parts house-brewed unsweetened black tea and homemade lemonade.
- Zesty GingeradeA refreshing beverage that combines the tangy flavor of freshly squeezed lemonade with the bold, spicy kick of ginger.
- Milk
- Chocolate Milk
- Orange Juice
- Specialty SodaFeaturing Pepsi & Diet Pepsi Dr. Brown's (cherry, diet cherry, cream soda, diet cream soda, cel-ray, ginger ale) Bubly Flavor Sparkling Water Grapefruit, Peach
- Bottled WaterNatural Alpine Spring Crystal Geyser.
Catering
Please place your order at least 24 hours ahead to allow for additional prep time
- Riverside Park PlatterNY Dozen (13 bagels), 1 lb Atlantic cold smoked salmon, 2 8-oz spreads, arugula, tomato, cucumber, pickles, red onion, and capers.
- Westchester PlatterNY Dozen (13 bagels), 1 lb tuna salad, 1 lb smoked whitefish salad, 2 8oz spreads, arugula, tomato, cucumber, Gotham's Finest Pickles, red onions, and capers.
- Crown Heights PlatterNY Dozen (13 bagels), 2lbs pastrami, 2-8oz spreads, Gotham's Finest Pickles, mustard, arugula, tomato, and giardiniera.
- Long Island PlatterNY Dozen (13 bagels), 1 lb House Roasted Turkey, 1 lb sliced Fontina cheese 2-8oz spreads, arugula, tomato, cucumber, pickles, red onion, and capers.
- Latke PlatterTwo dozen latkes, snake bite hot sauce, sour cream, and homemade apple sauce.
- Half Pan Scrambled Eggs*Scrambled eggs for catering orders, serves 15-20
- Half Pan BaconBacon for catering, serves 15-20
- Cookie Tray6 Salted Brown Butter Chocolate Chunk, 6 Black and White cookies
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness. Menu items may contain or come into contact with wheat, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, and milk.
Mouth Watering Yet?
Get more details about our bagels or find your nearest location below for current availability and menu details.